|
Post by ironhold on Nov 8, 2012 3:47:35 GMT
During one of the re-visits of the Archimedes Mirror myth, Jamie noted that the reflectivity of the mirrors was fairly blinding and that, while the ray wasn't enough to start a fire, it was still rather warm.
This is leading me to wonder.
Suppose that the true effect of the mirror, if it existed, wasn't to burn the invading fleet, but rather to blind the enemy's marksmen and make the crews as uncomfortable as possible.
A hypothetical experiment could consist of archers attempting to hit a target under normal circumstances and - if there's a way that this could be done safely - having them attempt to hit the same target while subject to a light of a similar intensity.
If the archers show a marked increase in the rate of misses while trying to shoot against the light, then it could potentially be said that the mirror wouldn't have been wholly ineffective... especially since the defending archers wouldn't have been so blinded.
|
|
|
Post by the light works on Nov 8, 2012 14:58:01 GMT
I believe I had mentioned after the FIRST bust that perhaps the mirrors just distracted the crews while archers fired flaming arrows at the boats.
|
|
bioLarzen
Demi-Minion
"I reject your avatars and substitute my own."
Posts: 86
|
Post by bioLarzen on Jan 8, 2013 11:56:05 GMT
Well, i guess the possibility is there. Too bad we will never know.
bio
|
|
|
Post by Cybermortis on Jan 8, 2013 22:28:40 GMT
I believe I had mentioned after the FIRST bust that perhaps the mirrors just distracted the crews while archers fired flaming arrows at the boats. Why bother? Blinding the men on deck isn't going to net to any real advantage. True, you *might* spoil the aim of the Roman archers a little, but you already have the twin advantages of greater range over them and better protection. Archers were the machine gunners of their (very lengthy) period, in that they relied on volume of fire rather than pin point accuracy. So tactically you'd be better off deploying more archers than having even a small number of men standing their shields in hand - who could not fire a bow while holding their shield. I also seriously doubt that the convex Greek shields would 'blind' an opponent long enough or badly enough to cause them any problems. While Jamie did note that he was blinded by the light during the testing, the 'shields' being used were flat. It certainly isn't going to cause any problems for the rowers* since they would be facing the stern of the ship rather than the walls. (*Remember, we are talking about galleys not sailing ships)
|
|